THE STEPFATHER (2009)
Reviewed by Jerry Saravia
Hollywood is so remake-happy nowadays that they'll even remake slasher/horror movies that were box-office failures. 1987's "The Stepfather"
was a hell of a Hitchcockian suspense thriller yet, outside of L.A.
and New York, it didn't perform well and only received an audience
when it debuted on cable. Lead actor Terry O'Quinn (who is now known
for TV's "Lost") was so terrifyingly maniacal in it, complete with a
"Leave it to Beaver" complex about family life, that his stepfather
remains one of the best psychopaths ever seen on the silver screen.
O'Quinn returned for the first sequel (which wasn't bad) and the series ended with an
abominable TV-movie sequel which did not feature O'Quinn. Twenty-years-later we get a remake that is
neither as good nor as bad as other slasher flicks, but just as silly,
undernourished and flavorless.Murderous stepdaddy is now played by Dylan Walsh, who calmly walks out of his home after killing his entire family. He moves to a new town, becomes David Harris, has a meet-cute to end all meet-cutes in a supermarket where he runs into Susan Harding (played by Sela Ward), falls for her, moves in with her, and gets a job through Susan's sister (played winningly and smartly by Paige Turco). Of course, David has no social security card, no work history under the assumed name, and naturally Susan's sister gets suspicious. Then David's neighbor gets suspicious after seeing someone bearing the same facial features on America's Most Wanted (thank you John Walsh - no relation to Dylan). Of course, David stupidly checks online for his notoriety on America's Most Wanted website (O'Quinn's stepdaddy would never have done that). Plus, there is the new stepson who just go back from military school and whom David tries to get along with (stepdad has a problem with his boy's skimpily-dressed girlfriend). Yeah, David wants family so badly, he'll kill them and move on if they disappoint him (or if they find out who he really is). I want to say bring back the delightful Jill Schoelen, who played O'Quinn's stepdaughter in the original, but I hate to be too obvious. She could've played Sela Ward's part since Sela is wasted in the role.
Red herring after red herring, "The Stepfather" has too many characters and too many set-ups without any real payoffs. This is essentially an overstuffed, undercooked bore of a movie. The PG-13 rating may have a lot to do with it since the ads suggest a "Disturbia" comparison. Comparing one mediocre movie to another doesn't help. The performances are adequate and yet too facile, too unpenetrating. Nothing in this movie seems to evolve like the thriller counterpart of the 1987 original. It is more like an over-the-top TV-movie about a stepdad who happens to be evil, but with little visual investment in the overall feel of the community with its tree-lined avenues, picket fences and so on - we never get a full picture of suburbia the way the original cinematic shocker managed.
Competently made with the usual array of false scares and a sillier ending to boot than in most thrillers of this type, "The Stepfather" might bring the occasional shock to the system but it is far too nondescript to succeed wholly. Only Paige Turco brings an element of surprise and a small measure of depth (she is a lesbian hooked on Sherry Stringfield, the latter of whom you might know from TV's "E.R."). This Turco character would have enraged O'Quinn's character two decades ago. In the 21st century, the stepdad just wants her to stay out of his forged work history. That's progress, I suppose.











