CAROL (2015)
Reviewed by Jerry Saravia
The most heartrending aspect about Todd Haynes' "Carol" is that a passionate love between two people is slowly diminishing, yet it is also getting stronger. So ultimately we feel a love has been lost due to foreseeable circumstances only to be deemed everlasting. Such is the beauty of this most stellar film and, although love between two women is not a novelty in 2015, it is the depiction of it that rises above most any other films. Fact is that, aside from Haynes' masterpiece "Far From Heaven," I do not recall seeing such elegance and beauty in romantically engaging strokes with a modicum of passionate love set during such a turbulent time like the 1950s. "Carol" has all that.Modicum of passion is expected in a tale set in the 1950's. A timid, introspective, aspiring photographer who works at Frankenberg's department store, Therese (Rooney Mara, remarkable in every sense of the word), has her sad Santa hat on as she works during the hustle and bustle of the Christmas season. She spots one woman in a fur coat, Carol (Cate Blanchett), who makes eye contact with Therese. A moment is exchanged. A gift is purchased, that being a train set for Carol's daughter. Phone numbers are exchanged. Not much ensues, and yet so much has happened. Therese and Carol are intrigued by each other because they dared to notice each other. Before you know it, Carol wants to show her appreciation for Therese's helpful customer service by inviting her to her country home. Carol is going through a tough divorce, and Therese is merely unsure if she wants to be with her beau who is asking her to travel with him to Europe. When Theresa is invited to go on a road trip with Carol, there is no hesitation.
"Carol" is sublime in its absolute restraint and its exquisite study of manners and implicit body language. Only Cate Blanchett could give another woman the impression of romantic interest without saying a word. Carol is going through severe turmoil over her divorce and whether she can have joint custody of her precious daughter. In some ways, Cate's performance reminds me of her brilliant role in "Blue Jasmine" only this wealthy woman can't show much weakness or vulnerability, except when she is in Therese's company. She reminds her soon-to-be ex (Kyle Chandler) that she can take a stand for herself, and reminds her former in-laws that a psychotherapist is not a doctor. Carol finds her footing whereas Jasmine's strength dissipates.
Therese is the quiet woman who has trouble making connections with others. She turns down a romantic fling with a New York Times wannabe writer. She can't fathom why her boyfriend will not sleep with her despite his admittance he has had anonymous sex with two other women. A curtain of loneliness surrounds Therese especially when she is her darkroom, or sitting in a rain-drenched car. The saddest image of all is watching her in the department store with her Santa hat - nobody seems to notice her. An early flash-forward scene of Therese with Carol at a ritzy restaurant shows Therese growing more and more disconnected, at least to other people but not to Carol. What is most remarkable about Rooney Mara is that she conveys her observations of others through acute glances, once again proving that less is more. I expect Academy Award wins for both actresses - their work is a master class in how much one can convey without words.
"Carol" is based on a partly autobiographical novel by Patricia Highsmith (she initially used a pseudonym when it was published) and, though there are some slight changes, the film bravely echoes a deep secret where two women have to keep their passion guarded yet can't resist each other. It is the repressive 1950's and, not unlike Haynes' "Far From Heaven" set during the same era and also depicting a secret love affair that is likely to burst the moral code of the times, "Carol" gives us a glimmer of hope, not necessarily a sunny disposition with a pseudo happy ending. Haynes, one of our giant national treasures of cinema, foreshadows something glorious between Therese and Carol, mostly through the hint of the color red (note the traffic stop red signals and the red lampshades in the final scene). To these two women, lesbianism is not their phrase, it is society's. For Carol and Therese, love is their higher calling.








