ST. ELMO'S FIRE (1985)
Revisited by Jerry Saravia
When I think of the occasionally MTV-flashy style of director Joel Schumacher, who died after a year of battling cancer in June of 2020, I think of films as diverse as 1983's marijuana-stoked, hazily comedic "D.C. Cab"; the diverting if far too romanticized-with-death thriller "Flatliners" with Julia Roberts; the humorous, incredibly entertaining (and glamorous-looking) "The Lost Boys"; the incredibly foolish and contrived cartoon called "Falling Down" with a loony Michael Douglas, and his garish-colored sequel "Batman Forever" and the ill-advised "Batman and Robin" that destroyed the Caped Crusader's cinematic interpretations for almost twenty years. Schumacher always presented, with certain exceptions, good-looking actors in artful poses for a magazine spread rather than a movie, though he has maintained some consistency in knowing how to direct actors. The one Schumacher film that gnaws at me, the first one I thought of when his unfortunate death was announced, is 1985's "St. Elmo's Fire," the last major Brat Pack movie (the only other one was "The Breakfast Club" released the same year). Yes, the one about college graduates from Georgetown that starred equally flashy, glamorous movie stars such as Judd Nelson, Ally Sheedy, Demi Moore, Emilio Estevez, Andrew McCarthy and Rob Lowe. Well, they were movie stars to some degree yet it was really Demi Moore who branched out and made a startling movie career headlining lead roles (the others did well on their own but the most financially successful was Moore). Nevertheless, something still gets to me about "St. Elmo's Fire" because it is not a good movie yet it is a watchable one with flashes of something humanistic. The dialogue, despite sounding artificial, is memorable in its own way. The actors are not at their best yet they still shine through along with top pros like Mare Winningham and Martin Balsam. Nothing in the film is believable, not one note or characterization excepting by Winningham and Balsam, yet I accept the unbelievability, the degree to which these actors somehow make it seem real enough, I suppose. Or not, I am not sure. What is it about "St. Elmo's Fire" that still makes me want to revisit it? Let's dig.
Judd Nelson is Alec, the sole Republican of the group, wanting to marry architect Leslie (Ally Sheedy) so that he can stop cheating on her. This relationship, by the way, is not the least bit credible though I suppose it is understandable because what the hell does she see in Nelson (nope, it has nothing to do with Alec's political party choice). At the start of the film, saxophonist and womanizing husband (Rob Lowe, who is about as suitably cast as Michael J. Fox was as a working-class rock singer in "Light of Day") is arrested for drunk driving, woos a female paramedic, apologizes to his girlfriend-of-sorts Wendy (mousy-looking Mare Winningham) and is egged on by Alec and his friends. Then we shift to the lives of this group of college graduates facing a mid-life crisis of one sort or another. Kirby (Emilio Estevez) works at the favorite hangout of these yuppies, St. Elmo's Bar, abandoning medical school in his future since he might be interested in law school, or vice versa. In the meantime, after losing his waiter job, Kirby really wants to impress a doctor (Andie MacDowell) who is on call 24 hours a day. How does he impress? He arrives in a limo, showing off as an attache to a Korean businessman. Kirby is all about money and thinks that is all the doctor ordered. Meanwhile, we got the writer Kevin (Andrew McCarthy), roommates with Kirby, who believes love sucks yet is hopelessly infatuated with Leslie - though everyone falsely believes Kevin is actually in love with Alec! Kevin wants to publish an article on the meaning of life at the Washington Post - I don't think they would care but somehow he miraculously gets published! Oh, Demi Moore plays a flirtatious banker named Jules who drinks too much and is obsessed with her grandmother's funeral arrangements. Last but not least is the virginal Wendy (Mare Winningham) who pines for Billy, though this relationship in hindsight doesn't make much sense either.
Yet "St. Elmo's Fire" still manages to be entertaining fluffy nonsense. The ending is moving in its own way despite it not being warranted (Billy shows a more compassionate side when he is not drinking). I like the film technically - it is well-made and has stunning close-up shots particularly of Sheedy. Schumacher clearly loves his actors and often frames them as a group - I think he also likes these characters though some are smug and self-satisfied. Wendy is the one character who wants to break free of her family's wealth and help people as a social worker - she wants responsibilities and wants to be a mature adult. Except for Leslie, the rest of the group is eager to party, cheat, and lie and generally make fools of themselves. Materialism and money are considered attainable virtues and what would you expect from an 80's movie like this one? The ending seems to suggest that maintaining friends is more important. I hate to say it but the artfully glamorous way in which these yuppies are presented still sucks me in - it is entrancing though I am not sure the movie works at all. This is the first guilty-pleasure movie I can think of where I feel ashamed, not guilty, for liking it.









