Let it be said: the last time that M. Night Shyamalan directed an apocalyptic tale, it was a sign of an impending cinematic apocalypse. No Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse were needed to foretell that impending disaster called "The Happening" and that was the last Nightman movie I had seen for a while. Until now. Only now the Nightman has chosen to adapt a novel and write it as a gloom-and-doom tale with some shred of optimism. "Knock at the Cabin" is intriguing for a while yet it falls apart towards its climax and leaves us with more questions than answers. Normally that would work within the framework of a movie like this but the questions linger and made me wonder why this tale needed to be woven this way.
7-year-old Wen (Kristen Cui) is collecting grasshoppers in a mason jar to study them and see how they react to their environment. Wen is in the middle of the woods near a cabin when she spots a huge figure in the background walking towards her. He is Leonard (Dave Bautista), a kind and gentle man who explains to Wen that he is on a mission and has to save the world. Before Wen can question Leonard's odd mission, three other people materialize out of the woods with makeshift weapons. Wen runs to her two adopted dads at the cabin, Eric (Jonathan Groff) and Andrew (Ben Aldridge), and suddenly we think this is a home invasion. Or maybe these strange people emerging from the woods are bigots who feel same-sex couples are ruining our world. Let it be said that I did not expect these four people to be pontificating about an end of the world scenario where someone from the chosen small family unit needs to be sacrificed to save it. Will the disbelieving Eric or Andrew sacrifice Wen or themselves? Only one need be sacrificed, but why this family? Apparently Eric, Andrew and Wen show more purity and love for each other than anyone else on Planet Earth. But would anyone that pure of heart and mind really sacrifice one of their own for something seemingly unprovable?
The other members of this Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse are a nurse, Sabrina (Nikki Amuka-Bird); an ex-convict named Redmond (former Harry Potter actor Rupert Grint showing major grit), and a slightly delirious cook who loves to feed people, Adriane (Abby Quinn). Each one asks the two dads, now bound with rope, to please consider sacrificing someone in their family to save 7 billion people! Each time one of the Four Doofuses are denied, they have to kneel, put a cloth over their heads and be bludgeoned to death by the others! Huh? Then to further prove their apocalyptic claims are true, news footage is shown on TV of tsunamis and planes falling from the sky. End of the World or some sort of clever sleight of hand? Some of the news is prerecorded, and later some of it is live.
"Knock in the Cabin" still sort of held my interest for a while but once the plot was unraveled, I just couldn't buy it at all. The story is based on a 2018 novel by Paul G. Tremblay titled "The Cabin at the End of the World" and, though the novel is darker and more ambiguous, the story is relatively the same with changes in who survives and who dies. Director Shyamalan edges this story with very little suspense during some crucial scenes, and credibility is thrown out the window when the rules, despite being purportedly exacting visions, don't mesh with the storyline. Why would the downfall of humanity be centered on some log cabin in the middle of the woods? Why this particular couple? Why is murder a method of salvation? Shall I page Abraham from the Bible to find the answers? In Abraham's case, God merely tested the old man's obedience to the Lord. I suppose it is all Biblical at the end of the day but it doesn't jell in this movie and feels too heavily contrived, despite some urgency provided by Dave Bautista (he is becoming one hell of a character actor). All that urgency though is all for naught. God just doesn't figure in this apocalyptic equation.




