The freshness and emotional depth of "A Quiet Place" centered on a family struggling to survive amongst an unspecified alien species. These blind alien creatures have markedly hypersensitive hearing and respond to any sound decibels as low as the breaking of dried leaves on the ground (though waterfalls were an exception). The highly uneasy and brilliantly suspenseful sequel, "A Quiet Place Part II," retains much of that intensity and the emotional depth of the surviving Abbott family though it is not nearly as resonant as the original. That is a minor quibble because director John Krasinski is such a smart director that if you place this family in the same situation without aliens, it would still work as a finite piece of Apocalyptic fervor.
Day 1 is the title card we see in the opening flashback portion of the film where the Abbotts (including Krasinski as Lee Abbott, the father who sacrificed himself in the first film) are at a baseball game where their youngest, the deaf Marcus (Noah Jupe), is at bat. Everyone is distracted by some undetermined flaming object in the sky. Before anyone can figure out its significance (though we the audience know what it is), those aliens creatures arrive in this small town and decimate practically everyone. Flashforward to a year later and starting off right after the last frame of the original film where Evelyn Abbott (Emily Blunt), the mother, has killed one of the creatures with a shotgun and her deaf daughter, Regan (Millicent Simmonds), has figured out their weakness - her cochlear implant's increased volume is the creatures' Kryptonite and can kill them. The Abbotts approach a steel foundry where a nearby survivor lives, Emmett (Cillian Murphy), who doesn't want to help them despite knowing who they are and how they used to attend baseball games together. He feels certain people are not worth saving. Cut to a radio broadcast signal that picks up Bobby Darin's "Beyond the Sea" and that that signal may be coming from a possibly inhabited island. Regan wants to get to that island, hoping there are survivors, and all she needs is a boat. Will Emmett help Regan get to that boat at the marina and will Evelyn allow it knowing how unsympathetic Emmett is at first?
If the emotional resonance of the first film that included a pregnant Emily, a resourceful Evelyn, and Krasinski as the worried father who struggled to keep the family together doesn't make the same impact this time around, it is only because we have seen them in their crisis survival mode already. We have already seen these wickedly fast creatures who look like the equivalent of huge daddy long legs with razor sharp teeth. Yet Krasinski as a director can still make us respond with shock and awe as if it was new all over again and that is a rare feat for a sequel, especially horror, to practically rehash the original and still find us clinging to our seats. Rehash may seem like a harsh criticism but it is not - "A Quiet Place Part II" more appropriately gives us ample reasons to reinvest ourselves in this lonely, empty world in Upstate NY.
The suspense scenes still work wonders and still utilize quietness, if not as frequently as the original. For my money, Marcus keeping the crying infant inside an air tight bunker while the creature prowls outside of it is so tantalizing, so highly charged at such a maximum level of fright that I almost passed out. One sequence also had me clutching the arms of my theater seat when Regan finds a lonely train car with corpses - it is a scene that needs to be seen to be appreciated.
Noah Jupe is still the same frightened Marcus whose eyes well up in horror each time these creatures appear. Emily Blunt still exudes the warmth and determination of a mother who now has to protect three kids by herself sans the unfortunate demise of her brave husband. Cillian Murphy is an apathetic bastard at first yet he comes around, connecting with Regan and sharing the loss of family members in this Apocalypse.
Towards the finish line of this feverishly paced movie, we briefly encounter a group of feral humans who are not any less evil than the creatures - I wish this subplot was given more weight since I can't fathom why they live near the Marina. That may be the one minor flaw of an otherwise incredibly suspenseful, pulsating thriller that keeps you riveted from start to finish. I will say without question that Millicent Simmonds stands out as the true star of this movie - her strength and her drive to survive in a scarcely populated world of impending death gives her hope for a better, more beatific world. Now if only those pesky creatures would stop getting in the way.








