The most magical "Peter Pan" movie I've ever seen is the 1924 silent film version that starred Betty Bronson as the Boy who Never Grew Up. 1953's Disney animated version comes close. I never found Steven Spielberg's live action "Hook" to be enthralling - noisy, yes, but not the least bit magical. Though I have not been privy to the last couple of 21st century "Peter Pan" versions, Disney's newest "Peter Pan and Wendy" is often delightful fun, though never raucous, and has the right spirit and tone. This not exactly a compelling movie at all; just good solid adventure that will keep kids invested and entertained, even adults like myself .
I think everyone knows the iconic J.M. Barrie story quite well so keep in mind, with certain key differences, this is the exact same movie as the 1953 classic animated film. Of course, Peter Pan is back and played by British actor Alexander Molony, though he is not as rousing a Pan as I would've liked but he does have a kindred spirit with the previous boys in green tights (and don't message me with "well, the role was played by girls, too." I am well aware of that). There is a winsome quality to Ever Gabo Anderson as Wendy, the girl who doesn't want to grow up though she knows her days of playacting tales of Peter Pan with her younger siblings is coming to a close. Yara Shahidi is an exceptional Tinkerbell and she is ebullient in her physical acting since Wendy can't always understand what the fairy is saying. Kudos must also go to Jude Law as the aggressive Captain Hook who wants to kill Peter Pan - it turns out there is a backstory involving Hook as the former boy James who was abandoned by Peter. A momentous scene that I found moving is when Pan apologizes to Hook - a rarity in Pan lore.
"Peter Pan and Wendy" is fitting, colorful entertainment and legions ahead of Spielberg's dismal "Hook." Disney has been accused by a precious few naysayers of woke-isms which, by the way, there are precious few. Yes, there are some Lost Girls in the Lost Boys group (another key difference) and a lot more diversity than norm for this tale - that in and of itself is hardly something to deplore. Wendy also turns out to be proficient with a sword though it is nothing like what we saw Alice capable of in Tim Burton's caffeinated "Alice in Wonderland" remake. These are not flaws, just woke-isms which is a phrase I do find deplorable. For good old-fashioned entertainment with some jaw-dropping scenery making Neverland a place I would love to visit, "Peter Pan and Wendy" has a sense of periodic fun and magic to it. Sometimes, that is enough.









