The Sweet Sixteen Killer might be back in Vernon, a small town where not much happens. This killer wears a smiling Max Headroom-type mask complete with an arched eyebrow and, back in 1987, had stabbed three different high-school girls sixteen times on Halloween night. The latest victim in 2023 is not a high-school teen girl but rather a protective mother (Julie Bowen) of a high-school teen girl who has problems of her own, Jamie Hughes (Kiernan Shipka). Mom is attacked and killed by the supposed Sweet Sixteen Killer. Jamie can't hold back her tears and her father tries his best to soothe the loss. For a singular moment, I was reminded a little of Scott Derrickson's "The Black Phone" as the overcast tones gave off something unsettling in the air, not to mention the fractured relationship between Jamie and her parents. Pretty soon, though, the movie dives right in to Something Goofy This Way Comes as we see an amusement park that looks abandoned and unkempt yet still in working condition. Jamie is introduced to the park's one photo booth that is actually a time machine by her genius friend, Amelia (Kelcey Mawema). That's right, Amelia is a science wiz and no doubt that this invention would nag her a top prize at the science fair. When the killer comes calling for blood at the amusement park, Jamie hides in the phone booth and inadvertently activates it traveling back to 1987!
Once she arrives in 1987, culture shock hits Jamie like a tidal wave of a most un-woke era. The high-school kids are mean and use words like "fat" and some unprintable sexual scatalogical language. Her future mother Pam (Olivia Holt) is actually mean and bullish as well (yep, a reference to "Mean Girls" figures here) and can't begin to comprehend Jamie's wagging-finger-of-shame at these un-PC high-schoolers. These kids are rough and play dodgeball fast and loose causing Jamie to have a bloody nose (oh, poor baby). Ultimately, the 1980's is hard living and DNA is still nonexistent so fingering the killer with evidence will be complicated. Jamie aims to protect her future mother and the other three girls from getting killed but can she convince them she's from the future? Can she also convince Amelia's mother?
"Totally Killer" is a tasty confection to be sure full of refreshing surprises both comedic and horrific. The killer, an expert in karate, is truly a malevolent villain - his grinning mask is probably just as frightening as Ghostface from the "Scream" movies and the whodunit mystery resolution left me shocked. What truly stands out in all this tongue-in-cheek splendor is Kiernan Shipka who goes from dour teenager to an engaging young woman who has found herself in the dreary 80's decade - she may not appreciate the lewdness of the teenagers but she manages to help them find their humanity, including Pam. She makes them care and who would've guessed that we would find life lessons in a less gory, slightly elevated and highly entertaining slasher flick. Jamie changes history almost as often as Marty McFly did in "Back to the Future." This unusual movie almost made me want to go back in time to the 1980's. Almost.






