Reviewed by Jerry Saravia
While watching the longish, often repetitive yet somewhat watchable "The Alto Knights," I was reminded that Robert De Niro will probably always be best remembered for appearing in mob movies. From "The Godfather" to "GoodFellas" and "Casino" and a host of other gangland parts (some not so memorable), De Niro is first and foremost our favorite mob boss-type - he can play the part in his sleep. With "Alto Knights," he tries a double dose, playing mob bosses Frank Costello and Vito Genovese. The surprise is that one feels more inspired than the other.
Which is the more inspired part? De Niro as mob boss, associate to Lucky Luciano and seeking to be "the boss of bosses," Vito Genovese. With some prosthetics, it is a funny, wickedly spot-on performance by De Niro that feels like something he might have done 30 years ago. De Niro's role as Frank Costello, who is trying to be a legitimate "professional" gambler, feels like it is drawn from his Frank Sheeran role in "The Irishman" - very orderly and no fuss yet not much more. They are different roles with one performed with a sense of joy and the other performed as if De Niro just showed up, doing his diligent duty to bring the charisma but not the pathos.De Niro's big nose is not enough.
"The Alto Knights" is at its best during the last forty minutes where Costello decides to have a Cosa Nostra meeting in Apalachin, New York, to work out the details of gambling, loansharking, narcotics and much more (truth be told, this was really Genovese's plan to legitimize his role as the future Godfather). Costello purposely delays his attendance with every intention of showing up late if at all. There are unscheduled stops to buy apples and coffee. Eventually all "Five Families" in attendance at Apalachin, mob bosses and the like from around the country, try to flee when the cops start showing up and forming roadblocks.
"The Alto Knights" suffers from lack of character depth with regards to Genovese's insane short-lived marriage to Anna (Kathrine Narducci), to the point that they are so in love and then get a hasty divorce with Vito stealing from her club. Some of those scenes were grating like nails on a blackboard. Not much better is Frank's relationship to his devoted yet scared wife, Bobbie (Debra Messing), fearful that after an attempted assassination on her husband, he might not be safe in the streets even if he's retiring. The film also opens with narration courtesy of De Niro's older Costello (which basically apes "The Irishman") revealing the friendship between Genovese and Costello that developed into a bitter feud for power. Unfortunately, the film never develops that initial friendship - they always seemed like bitter rivals.
It may be high time for Robert De Niro to quit playing these mafioso types. I'll always remember him best as Jake La Motta or Travis Bickle, characters whom De Niro played like ticking time bombs ready to go off. There was also ample humanity despite playing characters you would least likely want to spend time with.
Despite the pedigree of journalist/screenwriter Nicholas Pileggi ("GoodFellas," "Casino") and the casting of De Niro and various other notable actors including Michael Rispoli's abbreviated turn as Albert Anastasia, "The Alto Knights" just feels merely adequate. It could have been a grand epic movie of friendship and betrayal yet it exists as infrequently compelling footnotes.






