HAIL, CAESAR! (2016)
Reviewed by Jerry Saravia
I love Hollywood satire and there is enough to admire from the Coens' "Hail, Caesar!" but I did wish there was more to chew on. The targets are there from Old Hollywood, from the Cinemascope movies that used to populate theaters back in the 1950's to the traditional movie fixer Mannix overseeing the production of a big-budget Roman tale, to hiding a pregnancy from a known actress, etc. As I said, there is plenty to look at in "Hail, Caesar!" but the film curiously holds back.
George Clooney is Baird Whitlock, a movie star who looks out of place in Roman soldier gear (Clancy Brown looks more appropriate in a fine cameo). That may be the joke of the film yet it is also the fact that Baird is not all that bright. He is kidnapped and sent to a Hollywood executive's home which is a meeting place for Communists who read books like "Das Kapital" and promote their cause known as "The Future." Why Baird is taken to this Communist meeting is beyond me except maybe to indoctrinate the idiotic actor or teach him the evils of capitalism.
Meanwhile, Eddie Mannix (Josh Brolin, exceedingly good), head of Capitol Pictures, tries to maintain several debacles at once, Baird's kidnapping being one. A cowboy star who can sing but can't act (Alden Ehrenreich) is cast in a sophisticated drama where he has trouble saying the line, "Would that it 'twere so simple." The impatient British director Laurence Lorenz (Ralph Fiennes) has an unforgettably hilarious scene where he endlessly tries to help the actor enunciate with proper diction. Good luck with that. Another debacle is DeeAnna Moran (Scarlett Johansson), the Esther Williams of underwater musicals, who is pregnant and has to hide it - the remedy is to tell the press that she has adopted. Oh, we also got two gossip column sisters, Thora and Thessaly Thacker (both played by Tilda Swinton) who try to get the latest scoop about everything, including Baird's alleged homosexual encounter with Lorenz in the production of a past movie. To make matters worse, Lockheed astonishingly wants Mannix to apply for a position, though it is unclear as to why.
I enjoyed "Hail, Caesar!" overall and any movie that has references to colorful musicals, the H bomb, Communism, Roman epics and untalented actors from a bygone era merits special attention. But the movie doesn't bite hard enough, it is content to swiftly move from one wacky situation to another without enough irony. Some scenes enthrall, such as the showstopping musical numbers, and other scenes lay flat such as the climactic submarine scene that looks as fake and staged as the movies they poke fun at. Unlike the Coens' own masterful Hollywood-skewering flick "Barton Fink" from two decades ago, "Hail, Caesar!" doesn't go for the extra mile or the comical punch it needs - it floats but it lacks a central motor. There are many scenes that made me laugh (love the scarf that nearly chokes a film editor played by Frances McDormand) and many that made me smile (Clooney giving a long impassioned speech in one take ruined by forgetting a line of dialogue). I just expected more mileage out of this scrappy though diverting poke at Old Hollywood.







