SALTBURN (2023)
Reviewed by Jerry Saravia
It is tempting to call the off-kilter, blackly humorous, sexually frank and deeply unsettling "Saltburn" a great movie. After all, it has a humongous final twist you don't see coming and it scoffs at the rich and powerful, showcasing them as nothing more than vain, cold-hearted people who just happen to possess a literal heartbeat. The latter may be the film's deep flaw, however, as it doesn't give us much of a chance to see the humanity of the rich or those who come from working class origins either. Everyone is dehumanized and the filmmaker chooses a dehumanizing approach.
"Saltburn" begins as a fish-out-of-water semi-comedy of manners as we are introduced to new Oxford student, Oliver Quick (Barry Keoghan, exceptional in every way), who is mocked for his student jacket as he begins a semester at the most prestigious of U.K.'s universities. Oliver has a hard time fitting in and is angrily shouted at by another student whom Oliver refuses to ask a math question! Sure glad I am not that smart because I would not have lasted beyond a day at Oxford. Oliver is deeply smitten with a popular student, Felix (Jacob Elordi), and through apparent sheer intervention, they become friends as they drink merrily and spend time together. Oliver's father dies and Felix comforts him, little knowing the more troubling truths about this fish-out-of-water who came from Prescot, a small town close to Liverpool.
Prescot is about as far removed from wealth as one can imagine, and Oliver is made to seem even more of a fish-out-of-water in terms of class distinction when he is invited to Felix's stately gated manor. Every room is the size of the most luxurious room you would find in an elegant hotel, and Oliver is quite taken by its size and scope. Felix lives with his parents, the loopy Sir James (Richard E. Grant) and the freewheeling candor of Lady Elspeth (Rosamund Pike, manifesting rather chillingly as a still life with a pulse). There's also Felix's sister, Venetia (an invigorating Alison Oliver), a nymphomaniac whom Oliver actually seduces. Between lavish parties and gratuitous karaoke, Oliver is not dismayed by the way the rich live - he's intoxicated by it and Felix and his family so much so that when it is time for him to exit the premises, he refuses.
"Saltburn" is a compelling story though too often it feels like a demented freak show, daring us to look at the screen when we rather not. I am no prude to sexually deviant behavior but Oliver licking a bathtub after Felix has masturbated is not quite my cup of tea. Same with Oliver's seduction of Venetia which is colored by crimson lewdness and I will leave it at that. These sexually frank moments are just that, frank but hardly colored by any true eroticism. The goal here is to shock and writer-director Emerald Fennell does just that. You want to look away but you can't help but look - that is some kind of special gift this anything-goes director is willing to pursue.
Yet despite all the open sexuality and the sublime performances that teeter on the edge of theatricality, I was less than shocked by "Saltburn" overall. The characters are keenly-drawn personalities and they stick with you yet precious little humanity is divulged. Oliver is a little loony himself as he tries to have sex with everyone, male or female yet we are never sure of his motives, at least not till the end. He is a liar and a potential sociopath yet I never gleaned much more than that from him. Felix seems like the most normal of the bunch, a party animal as it were who can have his feelings hurt.
While watching "Saltburn," it is superficially obvious that Fennell wants to present the rich as boring, bland, uptight people yet that is such a dull cliche at this point - there is no one to gravitate to or remotely care about. Felix's parents live a solitary life and have little regard for anyone or anything that impinges it. Same with Oliver, a young man who lies about his own family and craves Felix. The movie draws you in rather creepily yet distances us at the same time. You want to rub salt on the wounds you feel while watching this knuckle sandwich of a movie, instead of rubbing the salt on the wounds of the characters.