DONNIE BRASCO (1997)
Reviewed by Jerry Saravia
(Original review from 1997 screening)

Ever since "GoodFellas" burst into movie screens in 1990, there has been a renaissance of gangster pictures. The difference between the gangsters now and the gangsters from the cinema of the 1930's is the reality - the overwhelming verisimilitude of the scenario. We just don't see gangster plotting to kill others - we also see their family lives, their inner circles and their outbursts of violence, sometimes involving hacksaws and other gory methods. Some of these stories are based on actual events. To date, the best recent gangster pictures are Scorsese's ultra-realistic "GoodFellas" and "Casino" and De Palma's ferocious "The Untouchables." For more family-oriented, ethically acceptable gangsters crossed with a fascinating look at racial relations, you can look at Robert De Niro's directorial debut, "A Bronx Tale." Count "Donnie Brasco" among the best of the batch - a funny, brutal, galvanizingly emotional portrait of a man who risks everything just to join the mob. Never mind that this man is a cop.
Johnny Depp plays the real-life cop, Joseph Pistone, who went undercover in the mob in order to infiltrate them. His job was to have lasted 3 to 6 months - he went on for two years! Pistone assumes the name Donnie Brasco, a jeweler who can help Lefty (Al Pacino), an older man who wears gold-tinted sunglasses and works for Sonny Black (Michael Madsen), to determine if a diamond is a "fulgesi" or not. This mob group is at a lower chain on the Mafia meter, closer to the guys in "Mean Streets" than in "The Godfather." They wait in the streets in the freezing cold of Brooklyn for the chief mob boss. Some of them try to take anything they can for money, including the removal of parking meters!
Donnie is in this dangerous world almost immediately, thanks to Lefty who vouches for him. Lefty teaches Donnie the rules, like shaving his mustache, how wearing cowboy boots and jeans is a no-no, how to carry money (never put it in the wallet), never pay for drinks, and so on. Donnie is so involved that he fools everyone, especially after beating up a Japanese waiter for being forced to remove his boots. Eventually, after Sonny Black moves up in the ranks, more money is owed to Sonny Red (the chief boss is in jail, if I understood correctly). So Donnie brings up an idea of making money at a nightclub in Florida. They all agree, though Lefty has reservations. But Donnie is so deep in the Mafia life that he ignores his wife (Anne Heche) and three daughters - he only visits them when it is convenient.
"Donnie Brasco" avoid all the cliches and conventional trappings of most mob movies. The film, as written by Paul Attanasio, does not pussyfoot around Donnie's own safety in this organization or his downward spiral about becoming the very thing he is working against. Most films would show Donnie to be so banal and charmless and righteous that it would hardly strike a chord of truth. Johnny Depp shows this character inside and out, revealing layers such as his growing violent behavior (especially to his wife) and his incessant need to curse. And his vulnerability is also evoked as he develops a mutual friendship with Lefty - if Donnie leaves Lefty and is exposed, Lefty could be whacked for having vouched for an FBI agent.
Al Pacino plays Lefty as a weary, joyless man who has 26 hits under his belt and more experience than anyone in his crew, yet he is still working for someone else. Lefty is like the Wily Loman of Mafia types, and we grow to sympathize with a man who would love to leave the life and settle down with his girlfriend. Still, he hopes to make more money and Donnie could be the key to wealth - both men have a downward spiral to endure that is touching and intensifying to watch.
As directed with refreshing restraint and observational details by Brit Mike Newell, "Donnie Brasco" is one hell of a motion picture. It is explosive, humane, blackly funny and filled with some of the best written dialogue in eons. This is not the world of dynamic energy and profane violence of "GoodFellas" (though there is one scene that is not meant for the squeamish). Instead, it is really about friendship and trust, even if one of those is violated. Pacino's last scene, showing Lefty leaving his life behind him and his recognition of a deeper truth, is unforgettable. "Donnie Brasco" is about as great as a Hollywood movie can get.