Canadian horror films I've seen typically seem to skimp on gore and go straight for the jugular, so to speak (except maybe for director David Cronenberg). "The Dark Stranger" has some creative blood effects that do not overwhelm and yet the story doesn't seem to jell between the artist with suicidal tendencies and the art world, the process of creating. Can someone who creates a world that suffers from depression actually do it without medication, or is it willed by something supernatural?
Katie Findlay (Leah Garrison), who looks like Emmy Rossum's younger sister, refuses to leave the house and hardly ever takes a shower. She lives with her brother, an aspiring musician, and her understanding and devoted father, both of whom she cooks dinner for. Katie's mother committed suicide and left behind some drawings that has piqued someone's interest in showing them at a gallery. Katie can't bring herself to draw but when she stops taking her meds, the creative juices start flowing. Only this is not the usual creative streak that she can enjoy - something beyond her forces her to sketch drawings for a graphic novel called "The Dark Stranger." Of course, we the audience start to think this is all in her head but it turns out that by drawing these pages, a supernatural force has been summoned and wants her to finish the graphic novel. He is the Dark Stranger.
Writer-director Chris Trebilcock could have taken this in ways where reality and fantasy sometimes merge yet the distinction may remain at arm's length, at least from Katie's point-of-view. Trebilcock chickens out when he goes down the usual well-travelled path of horror films (though there is nothing as wretched here as the misshapen "Cellar Dweller" from 1988), and I won't say where that path leads but I think you can guess where. Somehow this occasionally tepid script avoids really dealing with Katie's depression. The set up is terrific and the first half-hour or so really forms the slightly dysfunctional family unit. Leah Garrison gives an amazingly potent performance as Katie and her mood swings feel completely realistic, especially when it leads to cutting herself. I also enjoyed Enrico Colantoni as the father who is troubled by Katie and her visions and still hopes she will come out of it. Also worth noting is Stephen McHattie as the Dark Stranger and a real-life stranger, an art curator, who is far too interested in Katie's mother's drawings - talk about potency, McHattie is a bit underused here but he still has a fiery presence.
"The Dark Stranger" has some intriguing ideas and I love the drawings of this graphic novel and how they come to life. I just wished it went further and that it did not progressively ignore Katie's mental breakdown and/or illness. Art is her salvation but only in a supernaturally superficial kind of way.








