HEATHERS (1989)
Reassessment by Jerry Saravia (includes Spoilers)
Talking about being an affront to the normally cutesy romantic teen comedies of the 1980's, it is only fitting that the cold-as-ice "Heathers" was released at the tail end of the consumerist 1980's. "Heathers" is wild, wildly uneven, rancidly black comedy purporting to be somewhat satirical though never quite crossing that stream without shooting itself in the foot repeatedly. It shattered the glass of expectations for high-school comedies in general, yet all that remains are bloody shards of glass. It is revolting yet I can't say it doesn't hold your attention.
The basic outline is that there is a clique of high-school teenage girls who calls themselves Heather, and they all play croquet. The parents of these girls are well-off and seem lost in Never NeverLand. Veronica (played by the bewitching Winona Ryder, who steals the movie) is reluctantly one of the Heathers and reluctantly goes along with whatever the leading queen Heather (a sharp-tongued Kim Walker) says or does. This includes outrageous acts like sleeping with high-school jocks, cow-tipping, and pranks of such low bar (like passing a fake love note) that they could only happen in high-school. Veronica's whole plastic, pointlessly cruel world comes to a screeching halt when she meets the troublemaker J.D. (Christian Slater), a student dressed in a long coat who looks ready to kill and maim anyone who gets in his way (in one scene, he shoots two jocks with blanks in a cafeteria). J.D. and Veronica talk over slushies and have sex rather than play croquet (thank goodness) and it looks like the rebel, the cool outsider, has found his own queen. Veronica hates Heather Number 1, so much so that the idea of making her violently ill pleases her. Only J.D. doesn't believe in an orange juice/milk solution but rather Drano! It is the first and only truly shocking death in the movie. Heather Number 1 drinks the deadly potion as a dare, unaware what she's consuming, and lands face first on a glass table. I think I stopped laughing and smiling after that.

After the initial shock, "Heathers" never quite recovers and removes itself from its initial satirical targets. It aims into territory that today would be considered either a documentary or some half-witted and half-hearted attempt at eviscerating political correctness or good taste (Just so you know where I stand with satires about suicide and bad taste, I love "Harold and Maude"). J.D. and Veronica decide that Heather Number 1's death should look like a suicide and her note should include the word "myriad" (a word Heather got wrong in a test). Then there are the two jocks who are killed in what is meant to look like a murder-suicide of two gay guys who were not gay at all (this would not pass muster today, nor 20 years ago). The school becomes embroiled in these unexplained suicides and the local news turns the spotlight on them. Veronica is saddened at first and then gets off on it somewhat. She claims to be naive about blanks versus bullets, yet they are about to murder anyone she and J.D. hate (one nightmare scene of killing a Heather is almost as cartoonish as reality itself). She writes voraciously in her diary wearing a monocle, and that is quite a sight - a Heather-like version of "The Catcher in the Rye" with spilled blood.
"Heathers" then falls into a horror-movie scenario involving J.D.'s plan to blow up the school (oh, boy, that would definitely not go over well today). Veronica has her limitations when it comes to violence and I grew to hate her and J.D. "Heathers" gives us no one to empathize with or to root for. No student of this school is pictured as anything more than a potential dead teenager. The adults are dumb and could care less, especially the school faculty who don't want any sermons on togetherness lasting longer than half a day . The world of this movie is bizarre, uncontrollable and devoid of humanity. Well, that is until the last scene where Veronica decides to befriend a bullied Martha “Dumptruck” Dunnstock (Carrie Lynn) who does attempt to kill herself by walking into traffic. This is after J.D. has gloriously blown himself up, saving the school thanks to Veronica who becomes the savior. Yeah, sure.
I've seen "Heathers" a couple of times since 1989 and, each time, I found myself getting punched and kicked in the face by it. There was potential here for satirizing the Heathers and the very idea of cliques, not to mention high-school life. There are shades of that but not quite enough - the spirited lunacy from its solidly tight first half-hour or so doesn't last. There is not much spirit or lunacy or any sense of wicked fun beyond its first act. There are "myriad" jokes on gays and suicidal attempts and they all kind of fall flat on their face. I still find the film eerily compelling in its rawness and in Ryder's dumbfounded looks and priceless smirks and frowns. Slater does his best to remind us that he could be as good as Jack Nicholson yet his character is an enigmatic psycho (just what is the deal with his father, a demolitions expert?) Watching this movie can feel like nails being driven into a chalkboard.